Sarah Shay

Meet Sarah Shay – Your Local O’Fallon State Farm Agent

Originally from Southern Illinois, Sarah Shay fell in love with St. Louis while attending Fontbonne University and decided to plant her roots in Missouri. Sarah is proud to be a State Farm Agent in O'Fallon, MO, where she and her team help families, individuals, and businesses across Lake St. Louis, Defiance, Wentzville, St. Charles, and the greater St. Louis area with their everyday insurance needs.

Sarah and her amazing team share a commitment to exceeding expectations and a passion for helping others. Every customer who steps foot inside Sarah's State Farm O'Fallon, MO agency is treated like family. Acting with professionalism, transparency, and compassion, Sarah's team makes getting personalized insurance a positive experience. So leave your stress at the door and trade it in for the confidence and coverage you deserve.

Sarah is also a believer in giving back and is honored to have the chance to support nonprofits such as Saint Louis Crisis Nursery, GaitWay, and Greater Giving. For Sarah, being a Good Neighbor means being someone who is dependable through life's ups and downs and who is able to turn every interaction into a positive experience.

When she is away from the office, Sarah enjoys spending time with her family. She lives in Lake St. Louis, MO. She has four children - two daughters and two sons. They also have two fur babies, named Boone and Gus. One the weekends, you are likely to find Sarah, unapologetically cheering for the Cardinals and the Blues. She also enjoys horseback riding, boating, and attending concerts.

Insurance Options at Our O’Fallon Agency and across the states of Missouri, Illinois, and Tennessee:

• 🚗 Car Insurance Whether you’re commuting on I-70, driving through St. Charles, or heading out on weekend trips, we can help you explore your options for auto insurance. Call today for a free car insurance quote and see how simple the process can be.

• 🏡 Home Insurance From growing neighborhoods in O’Fallon to lakeside homes in Lake St. Louis, we’re here to help with home insurance that covers your property, belongings, and certain liability concerns. Start today with a free home insurance quote.

• 🛋️ Renters Insurance Living in an apartment or rental home in O’Fallon, St. Peters, or Wentzville? Renters insurance is an easy way to cover your belongings against fire, theft, or damage. Ask us for a renters insurance quote and keep your items covered.

• ❤️ Life Insurance Life moves quickly, and many families across O’Fallon and St. Charles rely on us for dependable life insurance options. Whether you’re looking into short-term or longer-term coverage, we’ll walk you through your choices. Get started today with a free life insurance quote.

• 💼 Business Insurance From local shops to growing companies, we can help business owners explore business insurance for commercial property, liability, and more. Call our office for a business insurance quote.

• 💎 Personal Articles Insurance If you own valuables like jewelry, electronics, or collectibles, we offer personal articles insurance that extends coverage beyond standard policies.

Why Choose Sarah Shay – State Farm in O’Fallon, MO?

• 🌟 Years of experience helping families and businesses across Missouri, Illinois, and Tennessee

• 📍 Convenient O’Fallon location serving Lake St. Louis, Wentzville, St. Peters, St. Charles, and surrounding areas

• ☕ A friendly office where you’re greeted with a smile (and a cup of coffee)

• 📞 Easy ways to connect—call, text, email, virtual appointments, or visit in person

• 🎉 Community-driven, supporting local nonprofits and events year-round

Sarah and her team are looking forward to meeting you and to begin discussing your unique insurance needs.

Want to get started now? Call our office or request a quote online today!