State Farm® Insurance Agent Sarah Shay

"I want to thank Kari Buttice for taking care of my issue with such professionalism and expediency. I was extremely frustrated with my situation. It wasn't a State Farm issue at all. My daughter's car was towed by mistake by her apartment complex and the tow lot wouldn't release the car because her name wasn't on the title. Kari was able to help get my problemed resolved extremely quickly and calmed me down at the same time. This saved me from flying down to Texas to get the car released in person. Kari saved the day for me! Thank you, Kari! Tod Fagan"

"Sarah Shay State Farm Insurance Agency is the best. Kari was amazing and made my switch from Progressive to State Farm car insurance easy with way more benefits and I also picked up some disability insurance for cheap. Kari walked me through the whole process and looked for the best coverage possible with some good laughs. Thanks for the new policies 😁"

"I've been with state farm for a fews years. Charle the agent at the time really understood my needs and gave me the most incredible state farm experience. When he left I honestly thought I'd have to switch companies. I didn't expect to find someone who also could meet such a high standard he had set. That's when I met Kari. Kari is absolutely amazing! 5 stars is clearly not enough. I have adhd so I have so many random things going on in a 5 minute conversation. Kari really listens to what her customer needs are. If a question should come up she may not be to sure about don't worry she has you covered! The follow up is ALWAYS timely. She really does show what outstanding customer service is. I definitely appreciate Kari for her work and highly recommend her to anyone looking to switch companies. I promise you won't regret it."

"If you want personalized friendly service with a patient, caring staff. This is the insurance carrier to go to. Kari has been wonderful in answering questions for all my insurance needs from renters insurance, car insurance, and storage unit insurance coverage questions. She's very thorough, very knowledgeable and very understanding of each person's needs. Thanks again Kari and the staff at Sarah Shay State Farm Agency! Great people"

"As a car salesman, Sarah by far has some of the best customer service I’ve ever had the pleasure of interacting with. She listened to my needs, addressed any and all of my concerns with detailed information and made sure she was looking out for my best interests. She even has an amazing sense of humor on top and kept getting insurance set up entertaining. She is without a doubt the best insurance agent I’ve worked with and she has earned a long time customer in a couple of texts and a phone call."

"Anjalee was a tremendous help, made a very complicated day much simpler, and provided the best customer service I've had in a very long time. Even provided help on finding some additional information I was struggling to locate, above and beyond good service, thank you!"

"Anjalee Wood , She is absolutely amazing, very workable. Very knowledgeable. A great lady to have help you with everything. I needed and through the circumstances. I've been going through. She was very supportive. And she doesn't amazing job. I would not ask for a better insurance company. Or better people to talk to thanks for getting. I made a great friend of this and I know I have somebody trusteable and reliable that I can call whenever I need them. Thanks again."

"I received an annoying Request for Insurance Notification through the state of IL - even though proof of insurance is required to drive a new vehicle off the lot. The state does not allow the insured party to upload an image of the insurance card or policy. If you do not do so within a 30 day period, your license is suspended. I reached out to Anjalee Wood in Sarah Shay's office and received an immediate response that she had taken care of it, along with confirmation of clearance with the state. Thank you Anjalee for your prompt action - I know I will not have to worry about additional fines/court fees as a result. :)"

"Anjalee exceeded all of my expectations when choosing an insurance agent. She not only explained complicated insurance terms in a simple way but also made sure my sister and I got the best possible insurance deal. I also wanted to highlight Anjalee's best quality: her availability. Out of all insurance agents my sister and I tried talking with, she was the only one who was available to talk past 5pm; her availability, sympathy, and hardworking disposition are what led to doing business with Sarah Shay State Farm! Definitely to be highly recognized!"